A Personal Choice of Perennials
December 06, 2011
The arrival of a new book by Allan Armitage is always a significant event and, having produced my own big fat book on perennials, the arrival of a revised edition of Armitage’s Garden Perennials (Timber Press) is especially intriguing.
The first thing to say is that it looks great. All the pictures, all 1300 of them, are by the man - impressive in itself - and their quality is excellent. And his writing style is relaxed and infectious.
It’s also important to say that this is not an encyclopedia. It’s Allan Armitage’s personal choice of perennials. That’s fine, I respect his choices – we all know that he has a good eye for a good plant and with so very many perennials out there, and more and more arriving on the market all the time, we need plantspeople with insight to guide us to the best. Unexpectedly, Allan’s personal choice includes a few bulbs – Colchicum, Narcissus and Zephyranthes, for example, but no tulips or hyacinths, scillas or chionodoxas - and, even more unexpected, Clematis of all kinds..
Still, I’ve been dipping into this book ever since it’s arrived a few months back, and it’s become elevated to the nearby “reach for” shelf. But while the book is full of examined experience and insight, I’m a little baffled by some of the plant names. Hardy chrysanthemums are called Dendranthema, a name swept away in 1999 when botanists decided that changing the name of one of the most popular plants on the planet was, of course, a brief moment of madness. The change back to Chrysanthemum was even reported in the New York Times.
Also, the many and multicolored hellebores we’ve seen recently are covered under Helleborus orientalis. But these hellebores only feature such wonderful colors because they're hybrids, other species are in the mix. Hence the name for them: Helleborus x hybridus, a name first used in 1894 but which, to be fair, has only been widely used since 2001.
The other significant plant name issue of recent times, moving Cimicifuga into Actaea, doesn’t arise – neither are included.
It’s also only fair to point out that while gardeners on both sides of the Atlantic can appreciate the photography and the relaxed and insightful descriptions, this is largely a book for North American gardeners.
However, this is a book that will interest everyone who loves perennials, in spite of the nomenclatural oddities and the very personal selection.